Hinckley AFC’s fixtures for the 2023/24 season can be found below. Match reports can be accessed by clicking on the opposition’s name.
| Date | Opposition | Venue | Competition | Result | Att |
| Sat 8th July | Heather St John’s | A | Simon Blyth Memorial Trophy | 5-2 | 147 |
| Mon 10th July | Birstall United | H | Friendly | 4-1 | 117 |
| Sat 15th July | Quorn | A | Friendly | 2-1 | 117 |
| Tue 18th July | Coleshill Town | A | Friendly | 1-1 | |
| Sat 22nd July | Kirby Muxloe | A | Friendly | 5-1 | |
| Mon 24th July | Rugby Borough | H | Friendly | 5-2 | 141 |
| Sat 29th July | Coventry Alvis | A | Friendly | 3-1 | |
| Sat 5th August | Droitwich Spa | H | League | 3-2 | 202 |
| Mon 7th August | Heather St John’s | H | League | 1-3 | 252 |
| Sat 12th August | Bilston Town | A | League | 3-1 | 180 |
| Wed 16th August | Nuneaton Griff | A | League | 2-1 | 300 |
| Sat 19th August | Shawbury United | H | League | 3-0 | 167 |
| Mon 21st August | Coton Green | H | League | 8-0 | 201 |
| Sat 26th August | Eccleshall | A | FA Vase 1Q | 1-1* | 101 |
| Mon 28th August | Chelmsley Town | H | League | 2-2 | 232 |
| Sat 2nd September | Paget Rangers | H | League | 4-1 | 175 |
| Sat 9th September | Wednesfield | A | League | 2-1 | 80 |
| Fri 15th September | AFC Bridgnorth | H | League | 10-1 | 221 |
| Sat 23rd September | Bewdley Town | H | FA Vase 2Q | 9-0 | 229 |
| Sat 30th September | Allscott Heath | A | League | 2-3 | 112 |
| Mon 2nd October | Magna 73 | H | Leics Senior Cup 1 | 7-0 | 111 |
| Sat 7th October | Cradley Town | A | League | 4-4 | 137 |
| Sat 14th October | Sutton United | H | League | 2-2 | 221 |
| Fri 20th October | Stone Old Alleynians | H | FA Vase 1 | 1-4 | 162 |
| Mon 23rd October | Sutton United | H | League Cup 2 | 6-0 | 151 |
| Sat 28th October | Paget Rangers | A | League | 5-2 | 95 |
| Mon 6th November | Birstall United | H | Leics Senior Cup 2 | 5-3 | 137 |
| Sat 11th November | Cradley Town | H | League | 5-0 | 258 |
| Sat 18th November | Shawbury United | A | League | 1-0 | 82 |
| Sat 25th November | AFC Bridgnorth | A | League | 2-1 | 72 |
| Wed 29th November | Nuneaton Griff | A | League Cup 3 | 6-2 | 143 |
| Sat 2nd December | Coventry Copsewood | A | League | 4-1 | 81 |
| Tue 5th December | Ingles | A | Senior Cup QF | 1-1** | 80 |
| Sat 9th December | Smethwick Rangers | H | League | 5-1 | 178 |
| Sat 16th December | OJM Black Country | A | League | 2-0 | 120 |
| Sat 23rd December | Wolves Sporting | H | League | 3-2 | 188 |
| Tue 26th December | Ingles | A | League | 2-0 | 193 |
| Sat 30th December | Wednesfield | H | League | 4-0 | 220 |
| Sat 13th January | Allscott Heath | H | League | 2-2 | 172 |
| Sat 27th January | Ingles | H | League | 0-1 | 233 |
| Sat 3rd February | Chelmsley Town | A | League | 2-1 | 130 |
| Sat 10th February | Coventry Copsewood | H | League | 4-0 | 390 |
| Sat 24th February | OJM Black Country | H | League | 1-3 | 214 |
| Mon 26th February | Romulus | H | League Cup QF | 2-0 | 147 |
| Sat 9th March | Stapenhill | H | League | 4-0 | 218 |
| Sat 16th March | Stapenhill | A | League | 1-1 | 110 |
| Sat 23rd March | Droitwich Spa | A | League | 3-2 | 331 |
| Tue 26th March | Wolves Sporting | A | League | 3-1 | 30 |
| Sat 30th March | Nuneaton Griff | H | League | 4-2 | 352 |
| Mon 1st April | Sutton United | A | League | 4-1 | 287 |
| Sat 6th April | Heather St John’s | A | League | 3-2 | 247 |
| Wed 10th April | Coton Green | A | League | 0-1 | 120 |
| Sat 13th April | Bilston Town | H | League | 4-1 | 419 |
| Sat 20th April | Smethwick Rangers | A | League | 0-1 | 76 |
| Tue 23rd April | Highgate United | A | League Cup SF | 0-0*** | 120 |
*Hinckley AFC win 7-6 on penalties
**Ingles win 4-1 on penalties
***Highgate United win 4-3 on penalties